Korisnik:Antidiskriminator/Pesak

1. Serbia en.wiki - 8.500
2. Srbija sr.wiki - 65
3. Србија sr.wiki - 200
4. Srbija hr.wiki - 464
5. Srbija sh.wiki - 180

1. Belgrade en.wiki -
2. Beograd sr.wiki -
3. Београд sr.wiki -
4. Beograd hr.wiki -
5. Beograd sh.wiki -

Stari visokonemački jezik Предраг Милосављевић Apage Topovske šupe Milišićeva ciglana Trostruki surduk Hervardi Brižinski spomenici Kapetan Jorgać Paško Vasa Abdul Frašeri Centralni komitet za zaštitu prava albanskog naroda Avni Rustemi James Macpherson Mark Mazower Porodica Toptani Marin Barleti Hasan Izet-paša Međunarodna kontrolna komisija Salvia divinorum Osijan Ahmed Izet-paša Šefket Verlaci Karl Hopf Frang Bardi Kongregacija za jevanđelizaciju naroda prebačeno sa hr viki na sh viki Aleksandros Ipsilantis Harry Hodgkinson Člirim Peter Sugar Nacionalizacija istorije Globalizacija istorije Galaktoboureko Stefan Gečov Punđa

• Slavs were very probably present in Skanderbeg's forces, Dragan Gjorgiev said,

“George Castriota (1405-1468), now the Albanian national hero, stemmed from a family of landowners from the Dibër region in northeastern Albania who were no doubt of mixed Albanian- Slavic ancestry.” - Robert Elsie.

"Skanderbeg family came from the region of Dibra, which is now on the border between Albania and Macedonia. The area was inhabited in the Middle Ages both Albanian and Slavic tribes of the Orthodox Christian faith." - Oliver Schmitt Tages%20Anzeiger,%2025-2-2009..--Antidiskriminator 17:39, 9 februar-вељача 2011 (CET)

RSN

According to the WP:RS "The reliability of a source depends on context." Your question here does not present the context absolutely clear. Based on the section title from your link I will assume that your question is: "Are presented sources reliable sources for claim that Vojsava Kastrioti was Serbian, in the sense of ethnicity?" Please confirm if I am right.

I agree with Nuujinn that only contemporary sources and written by historians could be considered as RS in the context of claiming Vojsava's ethnicity, but that does not mean that all other sources presented here are not RS. Most of them are extensively used on wikipedia and referenced in historians works. Nuujinn only resumed WP:RS policy "Tertiary sources such as compendia, encyclopedias, textbooks, obituaries, and other summarizing sources may be used to give overviews or summaries, but should not be used in place of secondary sources for detailed discussion." That means that answer on your question is yes, tertiary sources that you presented are RS, but not for claim about her ethnicity, but for overview or summary (like within a list) about it.

I think that there are three sources you presented, which are written by contemporary historians and can be used as RS, but not for the claim that Vojsava was Serbian. Those are works of Oliver Jens Schmitt, Antonina Zhelyazkova and Olsi Jazexhi.--Antidiskriminator 09:54, 7 april-травањ 2011 (CEST)

rsn

[take it to RSN] sto je dalo ovo

| Komnen Bećirović, Serbian writer || Le Kossovo de l'absolu||Elle aporte des preuves incontestables, en particulier celles fournies par l'historien allemand Karl Hopf, sur l'origine Serbe de Georges Castriote dit Skanderbeg, heros national des Albanais, sur ses liens de parente avec les dynasties Serbes Tchenoyevitch et Brankovitch || [1] ||